NFL Dynasty Draft Semi-Final 1

[Nosferatu]

We selected players who were drafted between 1920 - 1983. Please vote for the best team and feel free to discuss...


Team G

QB - Roger Staubach
RB - Tony Dorsett
FB - Ernie Nevers
WR - Art Monk
WR - Bobby Mitchell
TE - Mike Ditka
LT - Joe Stydahar
LG - Mike Michalske
C - Frank Gatski
RG - Billy Shaw
RT - Rayfield Wright
LE - Lee Roy Selmon
DT -Henry Jordan
DT - Ernie Stautner
RE - Richard Dent
OLB - Jack Ham
MLB - Mike Singletary
OLB - Ray Nitchske
CB - Mike Haynes
CB - Roger Wehrli
SS - Mel Renfro
FS - Ronnie Lott

OR

Team J

QB - Otto Graham
RB - Eric Dickerson
FB - Jim Taylor
WR - Raymond Berry
WR - Don Maynard
TE - Jackie Smith
LT - Dick Schafrath
LG - Gene Upshaw
C - Mike Webster
RG - Joe DeLamielleure
RT - Jackie Slater
LDE - Ed "Too Tall" Jones
DT - Merlin Olsen
DT - Joe Greene
RDE - Jim Marshall
LLB - Bobby Bell
MLB - Dick Butkus
RLB - Isiah Robertson
LCB - Willie Brown
RCB - Emmitt Thomas
SS - Ken Houston
FS - Cliff Harris

 

[Nosferatu]

When voting please consider whether each team has its players in the position the player actually played during his career.


Thank you for voting...

 

[Nosferatu]

I got J winning 15 - 7

 

[Nosferatu]

QB - G
RB - J
FB - J
WR - J
WR - J
TE - G
LT - G
LG - J
C - J
RG - J
RT - J
LDE - G
DT - J
DT - J
RDE - J
LLB - G
MLB - J
RLB - J
LCB - G
RCB - J
SS - J
FS - G

 

[Ritzarmy]

Shocker you have your team winning

 

[Nosferatu]

Shocker indeed, I don't look at it like its my team vs your team. I went per position who is better. If you disagree say so, i'm ok with it. I would like to know which picks you disagree with...


I don't just vote for my team because it's my team I have actually voted against my team a few times doing these...

 

[skinsdad62]

my breakdown
qb toss up staubach capt comeback vs a guy who qb'd a team to 10 straight championship games
rb toss up dorsett or dickerson
wr i like monk and mitchell over manyard and and berry
te ditka is better all around then smith but its close
o/line even
d/line team J is clearly better
lbs nitchke is out of position so slight edge to the opponents
cbs thomas and brown slight edge to
safeties houston and harris have the edge

 

[Nosferatu]

I respect the hell out of your opinion but OLine even?

 

[Ritzarmy]

QB - G
RB - J
FB - J
WR - J
WR - J
TE - G
LT - G
LG - J
C - J
RG - J
RT - J
LDE - G
DT - J
DT - J
RDE - J
LLB - G
MLB - J
RLB - J
LCB - G
RCB - J
SS - J
FS - G

Are you serious you think your team has better LB's?

My votes 11-11 Tie. I always had better QB as the tie breaker.
QB - G
RB - J
FB - J
WR - G
WR - J
TE - G
LT - G
LG - J
C - J
RG - J
RT - J
LDE - G
DT - J
DT - J
RDE - G
LLB - G
MLB - G
RLB - G
LCB - G
RCB - J
SS - J
FS - G

 

[Ritzarmy]

my breakdown
qb toss up staubach capt comeback vs a guy who qb'd a team to 10 straight championship games
rb toss up dorsett or dickerson
wr i like monk and mitchell over manyard and and berry
te ditka is better all around then smith but its close
o/line even
d/line team J is clearly better
lbs nitchke is out of position so slight edge to the opponents
cbs thomas and brown slight edge to
safeties houston and harris have the edge

I disagree because he (Team J) has a better O-line and I believe a HOFer like Nitchke could easily play OLB instead of MLB so its not like Im using him as DE but still in a LB spot were he could excel in.

However everyone has a right to their opinion and I can understand where you are coming from. Thanks for voting.

 

[skinsdad62]

I respect the hell out of your opinion but OLine even?

sorry i made a mistake there the o/line with the exception of LT (even ) then o/line with slater , delamamluire , webster and upshaw is better at those 4 positions . i was looking at something else my bad

 

[Ritzarmy]

sorry i made a mistake there the o/line with the exception of LT (even ) then o/line with slater , delamamluire , webster and upshaw is better at those 4 positions . i was looking at something else my bad

Its okay just re-vote then

 

[Nosferatu]

Are you serious you think your team has better LB's?

My votes 11-11 Tie. I always had better QB as the tie breaker.
QB - G
RB - J
FB - J
WR - G
WR - J
TE - G
LT - G
LG - J
C - J
RG - J
RT - J
LDE - G
DT - J
DT - J
RDE - G
LLB - G
MLB - G
RLB - G
LCB - G
RCB - J
SS - J
FS - G

I gave you Ham over Bell. Yes Butkus is better than Singletary and you have Nitchske out of position that's why he didn't get my vote.

I gave you Staubach but if I had to really pick I take Graham, He lead his team to the Championship game every year of his career winning it 7 times...

 

[Ritzarmy]

He isn't out of position, he is still playing a LB spot which he could easily do. Graham I can see being better looking at championships.

 

[Nosferatu]

He is out of position, i'm not sure he could have "easily" played outside. I told you before playing players out of position is a big deal to me and I won't vote for players who are out of position no matter how good they were.

 

[Nosferatu]

This looks like its gonna be close...

 

[Ritzarmy]

He is out of position, i'm not sure he could have "easily" played outside. I told you before playing players out of position is a big deal to me and I won't vote for players who are out of position no matter how good they were.

Your out of position and out of order. Your God Damn right I ordered the code red.

 

[Nosferatu]

10 people in the draft and we have 8 votes?

 

[Ritzarmy]

10 people in the draft and we have 8 votes?

You have seen after people get voted out in round 1 that you have less and less participation. The championship game will be on Saturday and I think it should run through Monday at 5pm due to the holiday plus we don't get many voters on the weekend.

 

[skinsdad62]

i give less for having a guy out of position instead of a guy who really played the position other then the early 2 way guys . for instance i was going to take sammy baugh as a safety but someone took him straight up as a qb . baugh had 31 career ints

to me nitchke would have had questionable speed for an OLB but when he was in his prime i was a toddler

plus i thought you had to dock people if they had guys out of position